Nadir Bekirov: «Leaders of Public Organizations Represent Bigger Quantity of the Crimean Tatars, than System of Kurultaj — Medzhlis»

Post navigation

Nadir Bekirov: «Leaders of Public Organizations Represent Bigger Quantity of the Crimean Tatars, than System of Kurultaj — Medzhlis»

As it is known, the third session of Kurultaj of the fifth convocation has accepted on August, 29th the decision in which has urged V.Yanukovych to reconsider the decision on reformatting of Council of representatives of the crimean Tatar people. Thus delegates have referred that the decision of the head of the state breaks the Declaration of the radical people (are accepted the United Nations in 2007), in which is said what speak on behalf people name the representatives selected by it can only. We have asked to comment on this statement of the president of Fund of researches and support of the radical people of Crimea Nadir Bekirov who is the expert in international law in this sphere and regularly participates in actions, organized by the United Nations for the decision of the problems connected with maintenance of the rights of the radical people.

— First, I am amazed with cynicism which is shown that the Medzhlis and Kurultaj try to refer to the Declaration on the rights of the radical people. Because during an epoch of preparation of this Declaration not other as direct allies of the Medzhlis from party «National Ruh» and its partners, such as Ministers for Foreign Affairs Vladimir Ogryzko and Boris Tarasyuk (who leads party National Ruh of Ukraine simultaneously), have done the utmost that this Declaration hasn’t been accepted. It was made not by president Yanukovych, functionaries who simultaneously are appointees or leaders of National Ruh of Ukraine have made it. And now, you see offended Medzhlis and Kurultaj, that the president ostensibly doesn’t observe norm of the Declaration!.

Happen so that the line of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine has won the United Nations, this Declaration wouldn’t be accepted also by Kurultaj there is nothing to refer! Yes their happiness that, despite efforts of Ogryzko and Tarasyuk, the Declaration has been accepted by huge majority of votes of member states of the United Nations, and now they can refer to this Declaration. First of all, let Kurultaj and Milli Medzhlis persuade the «dostlar daima beraber», under whose list they again are going to be put forward on the next elections that those didn’t prevent the Declaration to work, that, at last, Ukraine has supported the Declaration on the rights of the radical people as it was made by variety of the states which initially voted against it.

It is very simple — let will declare in the Supreme Rada in which still there are members of their party, the corresponding initiative! Already both Australia, and New Zealand which in the beginning, at session of General Assembly, voted against, have officially declared that they support the Declaration. Now Canada prepares for supporting this Declaration. Ukraine disturbed to Declaration acceptance not at Yanukovych, and at president Yushchenko, has put to it a hand and Arseny Jatsenjuk, from the block OU-OS for which, without being sorry for language, Refat Chubarov urged to vote. President Yanukovych while to counteraction of the Declaration on the rights of the radical people has no relation. The direct relation to it have Yushchenko and Tarasyuk. All it looks, as in that saying: «whose cow would low…» . And here now the Crimean Tatars on the eve of elections in local councils of all levels urge to vote again for that party which has made in due time everything that the Declaration on the rights of the radical people hasn’t appeared. That is suggest to vote for the list which is formed by the people who have made acts, obviously hostile to all the Crimean Tatar people. Because to counteract acceptance of the Declaration on the rights of the radical people or to counteract returning of the Crimean Tatars from Uzbekistan, (as it has begun at the initiative of Ogryzko) means not simply to harm to those either other persons or groups from among the Crimean Tatars, this total negation of the rights of the Crimean Tatar people in practice. It is not simply cynicism a total absence of conscience!

Secondly, in this article of the Declaration it is said that the radical people on the procedures choose to themselves representative bodies. Correctly! But so that representative bodies, and Medzhlis and Kurultaj aren’t those because by own rules they lean against participation of one third of Crimean Tatars. Not half, not two thirds, and one third — notorious minority. This official rule on which Kurultaj is formed. Body which is formed on the basis of one third of any people that is a representative body?

In practice the quantity of the Crimean Tatar voters voting for present structure of Kurultaj, is even less — the majority from 1/3, it hardly is more 1/6. That is, even having rejected the numerous facts of jugglings at elections of delegates of Kurultaj, its present structure is selected from 1/6 to 1/3 of Crimean Tatar voters!

About what they speak?. They have the same relation to representation of the Crimean Tatar people, as to the Moon underside…

And, at last, so far as concerns that someone another, except Medzhlis, is included into Council of representatives… So, excuse me, each public organization or movement which exists in crimean Tatar environment, on the internal procedures and chooses the leaders, instead of under state instructions.Because in the law of Ukraine on associations of citizens it is told nothing about how directing bodies of this or that public organization are formed. It is a question only that the organization should be legalized by the notice or check in and that the structure of directing bodies should be known to check in bodies.

Public organizations don’t hide the directing bodies. But select the directing bodies without participation and without state control. Well, so the same it is possible to tell about the Medzhlis. He also informs in all possible ways state structures and officials on the structure: who is who and where enters. Than in this sense heads of public organizations, movements and blocks differ from a current Medzhlis? Yes anything. And at them legitimacy of participation in this council doesn’t concede legitimacy of participation of the Medzhlis which as is some years no more than one of public organizations of the Crimean Tatars. And it at the best if to forget about the jugglings, which steels already regular during elections of delegates of Kurultaj and Medzhlis of various level. And the Medzhlis though he nominally leans against one third, actually has smaller support as there not all this third which has taken part in elections of Kurultaj, voted for those whom offered.

My estimations of Kurultaj as non-legitive and the corrupted meeting completely prove to be true statements of its delegates, and also the officials of Milli Medezhlis who has hardly come back from its session. Sinaver Kadyrov: «… Any rests of democracy», are saved by Enver Abduraimov: «What list was generated Refat-aha Chubarov — it is not known. Pay attention: the principle of a course of elections of candidates was voted in the beginning, the list hasn’t been designated thus…», Ali Hamzin: «chairman of Medzhlis Mustafa Dzhemilev doesn’t supervise activity and acts 5-8 influential, we will speak, leaders in Kurultaj, who according to the positions allow commands to vote anyhow. This negative, it is possible to tell, is illness of Kurultaj».

Here those on!. I assumed that total control over its members from the individual head can be illness of democratic body. It appears, on the contrary, — illness, it when from under control of one person are other 5-8 persons, and behind them the others, moreover vote «according to the positions», instead of… With whose? Here horror!. Here «the democracy end» and «the rights of the radical people»!

And desire of delegates in advance the nobility whom on them will palm off for promotion on elections? Simply nightmare! Isn’t present that without looking to agree with the list which «was generated by Refat-aha Chubarov». Here then Kurultaj would be healthy»and« democracy triumphed »!

At such mechanisms of work of Kurultaj and Milli Medzhlis there is nothing surprising that in aggregate public organizations of the Crimean Tatars can quite apply for majority representation of the Crimean Tatar people.

Emir ABLYAZOV

«A voice of Crimea» ³37(872) 10 september

 

 

Похожие материалы

Ретроспектива дня