Without Control There Is No Result

Post navigation

Without Control There Is No Result

Here also regular session of Kurultaj which, unfortunately, has left more questions, than answers was carried by. The national parliament has ceased to be for a long time already mind, honor and conscience of the Crimean Tatar people, but it is interesting that with each new session all is more strong convinced of it the higher management of this body. This time they have been compelled to recognize openly — yes, Kurultaj is sick also it can be serious. Though the illness developed gradually: at first the clinic began to be shown, and now the pathology is appreciable all. All it became result of worthless, not conceptual personnel selection. Throughout all these years from system the Kurultaj-Medzhlis people of «long will», people with strategic and critical thinking were eliminated, people basic and responsible which weren’t afraid to put thorny questions and were ready to battle bravely for interests of the people. Instead of them the contingent loyal which won’t ask the superfluous began to concentrate, unnecessary movements won’t make, and if also the handle will overgild, please, any whim.

That is created within the limits of Kurultaj, beats a sickle on image of all the Crimean Tatar people, and thoughts on consequences of all these phenomena are capable to tire out any patriot in a condition of deep depression. The most insulting consists that anybody didn’t substitute us, nobody realized the artful plans. That now the system of national self-management doesn’t work and, moreover, rots from within, — the tragical error of Crimean Tatars, isn’t present the guilty more. It is a pity to recognize, but huge, enormous potential is artificial.

For reasonings last session has left that more than enough, we will concentrate attention to the most important as its urgency is caused by future national will. So, Kurultaj has declared for a long time already itself as about reliable enough springboard of occurrence in the power. At whom such ambitions are present — are involved in this body, and there already from mind, imagination and resourcefulness of the applicant the outcome of events depends. But practice has proved — who wants much, that always achieves. Though methods in this business — any question. Here and this time Kurultaj has generated the list of candidates of the Supreme Rada of Crimea, with scandal, truth, but has generated. If last time hard-fought battle followed a top-10 at present session all accurately understood — really to pass in parliament under the list of Kurultaj-Ruh has chance only the first three. In a fair wind case, at the best, four. It is connected, first, with essential changes in the law on elections according to which only 50 places in the autonomy highest legislative body will be played between parties.Secondly, the authority of Medzhlis obviously falls, besides the opposition in person Milli Firka, Coordination council of political forces of the Crimean Tatar people operates, and it is quite probable that we will see compatriots in lists of other political forces, even rather unexpected. So, it has been defined that Refat Chubarov, has a role of the leader, the locomotive, the person of political group will be number the first. Leonid Pilunsky goes number second under the arrangement with Ruh. Number three for businessman Enver Abduraimov is a person-beginner in national movement, in the decision of any national problems hasn’t been noticed. Besides it obviously irritates representatives of a wing of R.Chubarov. Number four is fixed to operating deputy Remzi Iljasov. Well and absolutely in unpromising position member of parliament who has conveniently taken place on several armchairs and a member of the government Aziz Abdullaev who has beaten out for himself only the fifth position. In comparison with the past at once (these are elections in local councils of the sample of 2006) the new person in the list is only E.Abduraimov, and the others represent, so to say, «gold structure». It is curious to remember that Refat Chubarov in rating voting of Kurultaj-2005 of participation didn’t accept. Then the majority of delegates of national parliament have accepted argument of Mustafa Dzhemilev about certain sociological poll (which published in full hasn’t been found out). By its results, R.Chubarov ostensibly had the highest rating, therefore he has automatically headed the list, accordingly, in actual voting of delegates it didn’t accept participation. Thus, R.Chubarov became some kind of a brand for which voters should vote. Actually deputy of SR of Crimea at that time didn’t gather, as carried a portfolio of Ukraine. This time we became witnesses of more basic approachdeputy of SR from his party, after all it has undergone procedure and has got the maximum number of votes. Because and last time R.Chubarov headed the list of candidates, it, naturally, along with the leader of deputy fraction bears responsibility for results of activity of current structure of people’s choices. There are no doubts that it would be very interesting to people to hear to the report on work both all fraction, and separately taken deputies. But, unfortunately, to inquire about what problems of critical importance were solved by the eight of people’s choices, it was not possible. According to the head of secretary of the Medzhlis Zair Smedljaev, somewhere in a lobby this point in question was discussed, but officially in a hall of session it and hasn’t sounded. On our question why the report of deputies and hasn’t been discussed at session of Kurultaj, and whether you consider such position correct, Zaire-aha has answered as follows:« I think, because delegates are happy with work of deputies. To tell the truth, deputies shouldn’t wait, while they will be asked, they should do it individually.First of all, it is necessary to him, after all they want to be the elite once again. I think, not absolutely ethically it is constant to ask them, they should do it under own initiative ».

Thumbing through pages «VC» (№46 from November, 11th, 2005) (year of session of Kurultaj before elections in local councils), it is possible to find out vast enough publication: «to Whom the servant of the people served?» . The material has been prepared by Working group of Medzhlis on studying of activity of deputy group led by Nadir Bekirov. The Editor-in-chief «VC» remembers Eldar Seitbekirov, then there were fears that Kurultaj will forbid to publish this report and blocks possibility to act head of the commission, therefore was decided to publish it on pages «VC». Today this material is the important historical document. And after all and it has turned out: is high-grade to report haven’t given. On the same time not to draw upon itself fire-spitting reaction, nobody has undertaken any practical steps at least to try to force to report deputies in the activity. Well, that the people in the slightest degree represented that people who of time in time aspire in the power have made. On purpose and owing to the possibilities to correct a current situation the newspaper «VC» again is compelled to incur this function. As the expert we had been chose one of the youth leaders, different the active civic stand, E.Bariev. Eskender-beat has told to us that the estimation of productivity of deputies develops of following criteria. First, rule-making (within the limits of SR of Crimea) or lawmaking (within the limits of SR of Ukraine). Secondly, work with voters, work in districts, meetings with voters, the decision of questions at local level. Thirdly, influence of the deputy or fraction on selective bodies, control over realization of a regional policy. The center of the political analysis and forecasting «Crimea» has carried out the quantitative analysis and has come to a conclusion that if to consider work of fraction Kurultaj-Ruh from the cadence beginning till April of this year enough small percent of initiatives turns out. From fraction K-R 4 decisions have arrived, they had more humanitarian character. For example, holidays of Moslems of Crimea should be the days off. For comparison the politician has noticed that at Party of Regions — 200 initiatives, at party «Union« — more than 100, not so many initiatives at Kunitsyn’s Block — 5, but they had economic character, concerned the investment policy.Considering in general fraction K-R activity, Eskender-bei is inclined to allocate both positive sides, and negative. It has carried active work of the Commission on agrarian questions to the first category led by Abmazhit Sulejmanov. He has carried following facts To the second group. First, in September, 2008 the decision on which the scheme of planning of territory ARC at which including there was a description of moving of the deported affirmed was accepted. Preparation of the such document occupies long enough term, passes the coordination of some profile committees. Eskender-bei has asked a question: what was fraction Kurultaj-Ruh position on this business? Why this document hasn’t been discussed at Medzhlis session? In turn the politician has expressed the conviction that in such occasion in general it was necessary to call Kurultaj. E.Bariev has underlined that considers this fact as an obvious defect of fraction in the strategic plan. Other fact: One of deputies, heading corresponding committee, has signed the decision in which including the question on working out of the North Baksansky deposit under an open-cast mine has been included. Local residents were perplexed, why making of such decision, deputies haven’t taken an interest at people who for them voted, whether they that the open-cast mine was developed want? A secret way, without having coordinated with local population (and this infringement of the law on planning of territory and town-planning of Ukraine), administration of Belogorsky area has signed this document, and SR Crimea, including, has given OK. The history has ended with that people have defended the rights, the open-cast mine for today isn’t in working out. And more the politician has noticed that, according to the Declaration on the national sovereignty, bowels, the earth and etc. belong to the Crimean Tatars as to the radical people of peninsula. And what becomes from party Kurultaj-Medzhlis and from deputies in a cut of an investment policy? Eskender Bariev has noticed that deputies aren’t always occupied by the direct duties. Besides there is a precipice between people’s choices and the population. And, at last, Medzhlis doesn’t define a problem for deputies. After all when there is no a complex of problems there is nothing to ask, actually. Therefore also it turns out that from year to year we don’t see any serious shifts or progress. «People who go in deputies, should understand that in parliament not only necessary to carry portfolios and to declare elected representatives of the people, and it is necessary to realize that it is the big labor-consuming, high technology work where it is necessary to think, it is necessary to work and show results. Often speak:« And what we can solve in parliament, after all we in minority?»It is not an argument. Speech is about other. We don’t see the initiative. In that case we either don’t need to go to parliament because we know in advance that we will be there in minority and anything we can not solve, or should show the activity, form the alternative policy. In that case even non Crimean Tatar electorate can see that the Crimean Tatars can offer norms adequate, quite realized and necessary for all Crimea. In that case, probably, and fraction Kurultaj-Ruh rating would increase at the expense of trust of the slavic population. We should to recognize fairly — first of all, a problem in us. I think that the part of our leaders thus creates to itself comfortable conditions, after all for a divergence it is not necessary to answer », — has underlined E.Bariev.

Actually, as we could be convinced, our deputies in the Crimean parliament look more than colourlessly. About any productive activity, not that for all Crimean community, and even for own people, to speak neither is literally, nor figuratively it is not necessary. Probably, anybody from them hasn’t wanted to report what to brag and there is nothing. Have felt ashamed or too lazy even that teaspoon of porridge on a plate to smear and give out for a nourishing breakfast. Today Kurultaj again suggests to vote for the same persons, for the same people who haven’t found possible, and, can, and haven’t counted necessary well though more or less decently to report on the people, the voter as they have justified its trust. How here not to reflect that the pre-election slogan «Dostlar daima betaber», probably, comprises certain other sacral sense.

Elvia SEITOVA

«A voice of Crimea» №37 (872) on September, 10th, 2010

 

Похожие материалы

Ретроспектива дня